Fungicide performance dose-response curves for winter oilseed rape

Our fungicide performance trials provide independent information on the relative efficacy of fungicides against phoma stem canker, light leaf spot and sclerotinia stem rot in winter oilseed rape. This page features the latest disease and yield dose-response curves.

Introduction

Data from our fungicide performance trials is used to plot dose-response curves. The charts show the average performance of fungicide products (disease and yield responses) across sites, seasons and leaf layers.

Curves that fit the data points well and have clear separation are most likely to reflect real differences (in terms of field performance).

To maximise differences between treatments, the trials use:

• High-risk locations
• Highly susceptible varieties
• Two sprays for phoma stem canker and light leaf spot
• Single spray for sclerotinia stem rot

Products

It is not possible to test all products in fungicide performance trials. The products are carefully selected to:

• Provide the most relevant results
• Give equal opportunity for agrochemical companies to include products in trials
• Put emphasis on testing pre-registration or new active ingredients*
• Include standard products for which there is good understanding of performance (to aid comparisons)

*Only authorised plant protection products feature in the dose-response curves.

Product list

Tested in 2024

• Proline 275 – prothioconazole: a DMI/azole
• Aviator 235 Xpro – bixafen + prothioconazole: an SDHI + DMI/azole
• Plover – difenoconazole: an DMI/azole
• Propulse – prothioconazole + fluopyram: an SDHI + DMI/azole

Tested in other years

• Amistar (azoxystrobin)
• Architect (mepiquat (as chloride), prohexadione calcium and pyraclostrobin)
• Filan (boscalid)
• Priori Gold (azoxystrobin and difenoconazole)
• Shepherd (boscalid and pyraclostrobin)
• Toledo (tebuconazole)

Dose-response curves

A selection of the key charts are shown below.

Phoma stem canker

Disease and yield response

Combined results for 2015–24 (16 trials). Toledo data for 2023 only.

Light leaf spot

Disease and yield response

Combined results for 2019–21 (5 trials).  

Note: Historic data is shown due to a lack of valid data from sites with both yield and disease data, recently. However, the full fungicide performance results include charts from recent seasons.

Sclerotinia stem rot

Disease and yield response (insert chart in row below)

Combined results for 2015–17 (5 trials). This disease is no longer a target for the fungicide performance project. Historic information is shown for reference.

Phoma stem canker

• Effective azole and non-azole control options
• Yield responses ranged from 0.20 to 0.55 t/ha in 2024
• Little benefit from applying more that 50% of full label rate (as part of a two-spray programme)
• Product differences in canker control and yields more evident when disease pressure was high

Light leaf spot

• Azoles, non-azoles and co-formulations effective and providing similar control of disease and yield
• Both azole and non-azole chemistry available for use in the autumn
• Timing of application important to achieve control and yield protection

Sclerotinia stem rot

• All modes of action available for sclerotinia control can now be used elsewhere in the fungicide programme
• Consider what active ingredients have been used previously within the fungicide programme and use alternation and mixtures for resistance management

All fungicide performance results

The full fungicide performance results cover all target diseases for wheat, barley and oilseed rape.

The charts on this web page show the average performance of fungicide products over multiple seasons.

The full results also include single-year data.

The latest results are released in December at the annual AHDB Agronomy Conference. These are available, alongside the presentation slides and video, from the fungicide performance home page.

Further information